The homicide allegation might be the beginning of a prolonged string of trials, which is unlikely to ever attain the highest brass
Earlier this week, an Australian soldier, Oliver Schulz, 41, was charged with homicide by the Australian Federal Police in relation to the killing of a civilian in Afghanistan in 2012.
Schulz was remanded in custody and is because of seem in court docket once more on Might 16. His trial will in all probability begin later this 12 months, and, if discovered responsible of homicide, he faces a most sentence of life imprisonment.
Schulz was a member of the elite Particular Air Service (SAS) Regiment – Australia’s shock troops that did a lot of the combating in Afghanistan. He served a number of excursions of responsibility, and was awarded the Commendation for Gallantry.
That is the primary legal prosecution introduced on account of investigations performed by the Workplace of the Particular Investigator (OSI) – a physique established in 2021 by the Australian authorities to find out if legal fees must be introduced in respect of potential battle crimes that had been recognized within the 2020 Brereton Report.
The Brereton inquiry discovered “credible proof” that Australian troopers could have murdered some 39 Afghan civilians and prisoners between 2005 and 2016. Investigation head Paul Brereton really useful that any prosecutions for these crimes be introduced within the civil courts, quite than earlier than army tribunals, resulting in the charging of Schulz this week.
The Brereton inquiry was established in response to stories by the ABC and Channel 9 alleging that Australian troopers had dedicated quite a few battle crimes throughout the Afghanistan battle.

Media stories accused Victoria Cross winner and SAS battle hero Ben Roberts-Smith of getting dedicated atrocities whereas on responsibility, prompting him to begin defamation proceedings in opposition to the publishers. The prolonged Roberts-Smith listening to was delayed by Covid-19 and solely concluded final 12 months, with the choose anticipated at hand down his judgment later this 12 months.
On the trial, the defendants, who’re publishers elevating a protection of fact, referred to as proof from plenty of Afghan civilians and SAS troopers. If believed, it might show that Roberts-Smith had, in reality, dedicated numerous atrocities – together with homicide. It isn’t identified whether or not OSI is presently investigating Roberts-Smith, but when the publishers’ fact protection succeeds, Roberts-Smith will nearly actually be prosecuted.
Schulz is believed to have been featured in an ABC 4 Corners documentary – though he was not named – that confirmed footage of an Afghan civilian, who was mendacity down in a discipline together with his arms raised, being shot by an Australian SAS soldier. That soldier is now alleged to be Schulz.
The Schulz prosecution is just the start of what is going to be a prolonged and embarrassing course of for the Australian Defence Power (ADF). The OSI is presently investigating between 40 and 50 extra battle crimes allegedly dedicated by Australian troopers in Afghanistan.
Fiona Nelson, director of the Australian Centre for Worldwide Justice, stated this week that, “Victims of human rights violations throughout the battle in Afghanistan have for many years been denied avenues for any accountability. Legal proceedings in Australia have an essential function to play in lastly permitting for impunity to be challenged. Australia has loads of work forward to reply to the legacy of its army engagement in Afghanistan.”
Australia’s involvement within the battle in Afghanistan – in help of the US try and impose a type of democracy and regime change on the Asian nation – has already confirmed to be a grave embarrassment for Canberra. Schulz’s trial, and the others that appear sure to observe in its wake, will little doubt add to Australia’s shame and disgrace.

Some 26,000 Australian personnel have been deployed in Afghanistan. 41 troopers died and 261 have been wounded. The battle in Afghanistan resulted in a complete army catastrophe for the invaders with the US and Australia pressured to make a humiliating withdrawal within the face of the resurgent Taliban’s return to energy.
The army loss in Afghanistan and the findings contained within the Brereton Report have fully destroyed the status and morale of the ADF, and the Schulz prosecution, regardless of the consequence, can solely add to the ADF’s woes. This was confirmed by SAS Affiliation Chairman Martin Hamilton-Smith, who stated this week that Schulz “has a proper to place his model of occasions and to elucidate the character and complexities of the combating in Afghanistan.”
When the Brereton findings have been handed down in November 2020, the ADF prime brass refused to take any duty by any means for the conduct of Australian troops in Afghanistan.
Army leaders heaped blame on low-ranking SAS troopers and appeared shocked at Brereton’s findings. A complete SAS Regiment was disbanded, and medals awarded to 1000’s of bizarre troopers have been peremptorily rescinded. Was the army management actually fully unaware of how the battle in Afghanistan had been fought, or, as is more likely, had the ADF prime brass merely turned a blind eye to occasions taking place in Afghanistan for years?
Moreover, the army elite’s enthusiastic help for Schulz’s prosecution shouldn’t blind us to the truth that this might be simply one other ploy to keep away from taking final duty for the battle crimes undoubtedly dedicated by Australian troops in Afghanistan.
Nonetheless, the ADF management’s dereliction of responsibility doesn’t cease there. It was the ADF prime brass that inspired and permitted troopers to interact in a number of excursions of responsibility in Afghanistan as a matter after all – absolutely an unwise coverage, and one that might possible result in the brutalization of bizarre troopers.
Additionally, it was the identical prime brass that drafted the inappropriate phrases of engagement that ruled the conduct of Australian troops in Afghanistan – guidelines that some protection specialists and troopers really feel brought on, at the least partially, the excesses revealed by Brereton.
It was the identical army management that did not correctly help these troopers who returned from Afghanistan in a traumatized state. In any case, it grew to become clear very early on within the battle that many troopers who returned dwelling have been unable to readjust to civilian life. Suicide charges amongst returning veterans have been terribly excessive, however the ADF prime brass did little or nothing to help these shattered people.
Solely when veterans’ organizations engaged in media campaigns to spotlight the difficulty did the federal authorities belatedly act. In July 2021 a Royal Fee was established to investigate into veteran suicide. The Fee is but at hand down its remaining report.
On account of Australia’s involvement in America’s misguided battle in Afghanistan, the ADF is now a damaged group. Its morale is shattered and veteran’s organizations and lots of bizarre troopers have misplaced all respect for the ADF management.
Nonetheless, the exact same army leaders that presided over the Afghanistan battle, and all that has transpired subsequently, nonetheless stay firmly in command of the ADF. It’s correct for bizarre troopers like Oliver Schulz to be prosecuted for battle crimes, nevertheless it ought to embody those that bear final duty for what occurred in Afghanistan – particularly the higher echelon ADF officers and politicians who uncritically supported america invasion and its aftermath – and they need to be held accountable and punished.
After all, that won’t occur as a result of – as final week’s AUKUS deal clearly demonstrated – the plain classes that ought to have been discovered from Australia’s disastrous involvement within the Afghanistan and Iraq wars are nonetheless being ignored by the political and army elites that proceed to rule Australia of their characteristically inept vogue.
The statements, views and opinions expressed on this column are solely these of the writer and don’t essentially symbolize these of RT.