Labor’s plan for Fowler was doomed to fail

Jock Webb writes: The ALP definitely deserved to lose Fowler (“‘Excellent storm’: what Labor received mistaken in its historic defeat in Fowler”). Kristina Keneally is about as far-off from actuality as you would get on this seat. I’m not knocking Keneally who was an efficient senator. It’s a severe indictment of the depressing factions in each main events that sees efficient members lose preselection to dimwits. The ALP ought to be doubly damned for failing to maintain Keneally in her Senate spot. Bloody idiocy.

Dennis Pratt writes: The ALP received away with imposing one other silvertail, Andrew Charlton, on Parramatta, so perhaps it received’t be taught the lesson. The factions are immune to studying. If solely there have been extra Dai Le independents who actually signify their communities, we may break the stitched-up offers the factions impose on the ALP candidate alternatives. The teals are doing it to the Liberals; we’d like the equal wake-up calls to the ALP.

Alan Robertson writes: The ends in Fowler confirmed the grassroots Labor motion that the celebration has little or no regard for the conventional individual. Labor stands for presidency by the linked however with out “U” — the labourer or regular employee. It governs from afar which doesn’t assist the area people apart from the “entitled”. Dai Le has proven that the “U” issue is an important and will by no means be dismissed. We’re free.

Roy Ramage writes: Dai Le is totally right. Locals don’t like outsiders dropped in so political events can profit. Labor ought to have famous that when Liberal Alexander Downer tried to drop his Victorian-based daughter into the South Australian seat of Mayo. South Australians instantly selected one among their very own. Australian communities want locals. Each events have been taught a salutary lesson. I doubt the number-counters will be taught.

Get Crikey FREE to your inbox each weekday morning with the Crikey Worm.

Richard Creswick writes: Sure, Labor deserved to lose Fowler. It had an appropriate native Vietnamese candidate who would most likely have received the protected Labor seat. The Keneally parachute transfer has misplaced Labor two good candidates and the seat. Lose lose lose.

Dai Le’s abstention on the Morrison censure and her reasoning point out she stays a closet Lib.

Gary Gibbon writes: Sure, dropping Fowler served Labor proper. The blatant parachuting factor doesn’t work. However in Dai Le, did Fowler voters get a midway respectable politician? Properly, judged on the premise of Anton Nilsson’s story, I’m not so certain. She abstained from censuring Scott Morrison as a result of it was “too political”, however on the identical time doesn’t need to be linked to the Liberal Get together anymore. Yeah, proper. Doesn’t she realise she is now a federal politician and will get paid from the general public purse to make selections not fence-sit over telling a vastly dishonest former prime minister how badly his unethical behaviour affected the Australian group and public perceptions of politicians? Sorry, Fowler voters, however I believe you continue to could also be lacking out.

James Parker writes: The morning after the federal election I used to be at my native store and ran into Duncan Kerr, a former Labor justice minister and briefly attorney-general. (He lives close to me.) I requested why Keneally — a real star within the political firmament — was operating for a decrease home seat when she had no ambition to be PM and was such a helpful individual on committees and many others. She was additionally an apparent candidate for a ministry.

Duncan mentioned that it was a easy downside of inside factional politics. Keneally had been dropped to an unwinnable place on the Senate ticket so, in desperation, she had been put right into a decrease home seat which a really likeable candidate, Tu Le, had an excellent probability of profitable. She had a margin of 18%. The truth that Keneally misplaced may be very, essential. The Labor Get together performed all of it mistaken, however please, take a look at the concept of ethnic voting.

Dai Le received as a result of she was Asian, and her Asian voters recognized along with her. This, certainly, is a failure of our supposedly splendidly built-in society. We’ve got not but divorced ourselves from our origins. We nonetheless have ethnic tribes. And I suppose that’s the means of the world. But when we’re to turn into an built-in society, we should always attempt to take a look at each other with clear eyes and attempt to see what all of us want. And learn how to make that occur. Not in “silos” of ethnicity.

This isn’t to excuse the Labor Get together in NSW — it received all of it mistaken. Each in placing Keneally, an actual star of the Parliament, into an unwinnable place and thus denigrating a genuinely good (and acceptable) candidate. Overlook the conservatives; the Labor Get together is its personal worst enemy. It’s about time it cleaned up its act.

Charles Klassen writes: Keneally is a former premier of NSW, and a assured and assertive parliamentary performer. Some colleagues say her confrontational political type is extra suited to the dynamics of the Home of Representatives than the Senate. When Keneally mentioned she would search preselection to run within the protected Labor seat of Fowler, she claimed she had been touched by the “enthusiasm and help” of native members who inspired her to run.

The transfer sparked criticism from HSU NSW secretary, Gerard Hayes, Labor MP Anne Aly and Osmond Chiu, who has led a grassroots push to enhance range in NSW Labor, on the grounds it will hurt multicultural illustration in politics. Hayes mentioned the HSU would “stand alone”, separate from the left and proper factions, because of a backroom deal to put in Keneally: “We will’t in good religion go down this line that no matter the place the candidate lives, they get put into seats the place there are lots of candidates that may signify what’s a culturally numerous group. Was there a democratic course of? I don’t assume so.”

Hayes strongly promoted a younger lawyer, Tu Le, daughter of Vietnamese refugees, to succeed him. She ticked bins on gender, range and native grounds. Keneally pushing her apart has induced outrage in some Labor circles. Aly instructed the ABC: “Range and equality and multiculturalism can’t simply be a trope that Labor pulls out and parades whereas carrying a sari and consuming some kung pao rooster to make ourselves look good”.

When you’re feeling happy, peed off or piqued, inform us about it by writing to letters@crikey.com.au. Please embrace your full identify to be thought of for publication. We reserve the correct to edit for size and readability.